Translate

Thursday, March 13, 2014

Bluefish Caves and Old Crow Basin: A New Rapport

Jacques Cinq-Mars and Richard E. Morlan
Archaeological Survey of Canada
Canadian Museum of Civilization
Ice Age Peoples of North America.
Environments, Origins, and Adaptations of the First Americans, edited by Robson Bonnichsen
and Karen L. Turnmire, pp. 200-212. Corvallis: Oregon State University Press for the Center
for the Study of the First Americans.

Introduction

     A cold, arid region known as Beringia played an unusually important role in the peopling of
the Americas. Stretching from eastern Siberia across Alaska to the Yukon Territory of Canada,
Beringia represented the gateway to the New World. During glacial advances, this region
served as a refugium for plants and animals, and evidence indicates that it was always available
as a rich habitat for human societies adapted to survive and prosper there. Beringia has played
a pivotal role in the evolution and dispersal of many organisms, and it is not surprising that it has
been the subject of special study by scientists in many disciplines and nations (e.g., Hopkins, et
al. 1982; Kontrimavichus 1984). Yet in many respects, Beringia remains little known and poorly
understood, and the archaeology of the region is one aspect that is still in its infancy.
     This paper presents some of the principal conclusions of Pleistocene archaeological research
in the northeastern corner of Beringia -- the northern Yukon interior. This is an extensive area of
plateaus, uplands and ranges bordering several large lowland basins (Hughes 1972; Hughes, et
al. 1981). During the last two decades, the authors of this paper have conducted research in the
Yukon. One has focused his attention primarily on the uplands (Cinq-Mars 1978, 1990), while
the other has concentrated on the lowlands (Morlan 1980, 1984, 1986). At the present time,
neither of these areas provides a complete picture of late Pleistocene developments, but a
provisional outline can be glimpsed by integrating results of studies in both settings.
     The paper begins with a consideration of paleoecological and archaeological findings at an
upland site known as the Bluefish Caves. The record at this site spans approximately 
25,000 years, including a lengthy period during which the lowlands record appears to be
muted by events marking the final stages of a late Wisconsinan glaciolacustrine inundation.
More importantly, the archaeological evidence at the Bluefish Caves has been derived from
a primary depositional context that provides a degree of chronostratigraphic and taphonomic
control not yet available in the lowland region. The Bluefish Caves evidence enables us 
to demonstrate human occupation in eastern Beringia during the height and decline 
of the last glaciation. The implications of that evidence form a basis for reconsidering older
materials from the lowlands for which fewer controls are available. In this process of
reevaluating the evidence from both the uplands and the lowlands, we are aided by new 
data from accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS) measurements on bone collagen.

 https://www.academia.edu/5521801/Bluefish_Caves_and_Old_Crow_Basin_A_New_Rapport._Cinqmars_et_al._1999_

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Out of Beringia? Not likely.

Out of Beringia?

A shrub tundra refugium on the Bering land bridge may have played a pivotal role in the peopling of the Americas

http://pure.rhul.ac.uk/portal/files/19079773/Science_article.pdf

"...Based on the distribution of tundra plants around the Bering Strait region..."

Really? That's it?

"...Genetic evidence suggests that most Native Americans are descended from a population that was isolated somewhere between northeast Asia and Alaska during the LGM..."

Absolutely no evidence to support this claim. Much evidence to the contrary.

"...The analysis of ancient DNA from human skeletal remains dating to 24,000 cal BP from Mal’ta in southern Siberia appears to confirm the pre-LGM divergence of Native Americans from their Asian parent haplogroups..."

1. Mal'ta is southern Siberia, not between northeast Asia and Alaska.

2. "...The MA-1 mitochondrial genome belongs to haplogroup U, which has also been found at
high frequency among Upper Palaeolithic and Mesolithic European hunter-gatherers, and the Y
chromosome of MA-1 is basal to modern-day western Eurasians and near the root of most
Native American lineages. Similarly, we find autosomal evidence that MA-1 is basal to modern-day western Eurasians and genetically closely related to modern-day Native Americans, with no close affinity to east Asians..."

M. Raghavan et al., Nature 505, 87 (2014).

3. MA-1 was clearly part of a Gravettian culture, which most scholars agree
originated in southwestern Europe/ Iberia. This is concordant with MA-1's
genetic signature.

"...At the same time, dated archaeological and human remains indicate that settlement of the Western Hemisphere probably took place after the LGM..."

I disagree:

"...At Meadowcroft Rockshelter, artifacts occur in sediments that may be as old as 22 to 18 ka..."

"...Cactus Hill...Three 14C dates ranging from 20 to 18 ka are reported from the levels below Clovis...luminescence dates on the aeolian sands correlate with the older 14C results and indicate minimal mixing of the sediments...biface and blade assemblage stratigraphically below the site’s Clovis assemblage is compelling..."

"...La Sena and Lovewell sites that date from 22 to 19 ka...many of the leg bones display percussion impact and flaking, which suggests that they were quarried and flaked by humans while they were in a fresh, green state, within a few years of the death of the animals..."

T. Goebel et al., Science 319, 1497 (2008).

"...Previous radiocarbon dating had obtained only lower limits of 40–45 ka BP for the Pedra
Furada basal layer. Nine charcoal samples from well-structured hearths were subjected to
the ABOX-SC procedure and their radiocarbon content determined by accelerator mass
spectrometry. Measurements on five of the samples returned ages of greater than 56 ka BP,
from graphites produced from ABOX pre-treated charcoal combusted at 910 C. Two other
samples were greater than 50 ka BP. The remaining two samples were essentially completely
combusted at 650C, with no material surviving to make a 910 C CO2 fraction. Their ages
were 41.3 and 47.2 ka BP. Ages obtained from graphites generated from the 650C combusted
fraction are considered minimum ages..."

A revised chronology of the lowest occupation layer of Pedra Furada Rock Shelter, Piaui, Brazil: The Pleistocene peopling of the Americas. Santos et al. (2003)

I could go on citing...

"...The shrub tundra zone in central Beringia represents the most plausible home for the isolated standstill population. Although high-latitude archaeological sites of LGM age are unknown, postglacial submergence of the Bering land bridge would explain the absence of traces of people concentrated in central Beringia...."

"...To confirm the hypothesis, archaeological sites of LGM age must be documented in Beringia..."

A whole bunch of them to support this hypothesis.

Charlie Hatchett

www.pre-clovis.com

www.forum.pre-clovis.com

www.blog.pre-clovis.com

Saturday, March 1, 2014

New Dig Seeks To Solve Mysteries of Old Vero Man Site

A major excavation initiative is about to get underway in Vero Beach, Florida at the famed Old Vero Man site, with scientists from Mercyhurst Archaeological Institute (MAI) at Mercyhurst University in Erie, Pa., and the Old Vero Ice Age Sites Committee (OVIASC) collaborating to unearth what they believe will be a significant archaeological find.  The site, which is named after the discovery of Vero Man in 1915 — the remains of whom are believed to be at least 13,000 years old — is believed to be the resting place for a bevy of significant fossils and artifacts, including additional human remains as well as the remains of extinct animals. The project will be headed by MAI director and principal excavator James Adovasio, Ph.D. Adovasio and MAI research archaeologist C. Andrew Hemmings, Ph.D., with Mercyhurst alumni Anne Marjenin, director of the Archaeology Processing Lab at Mercyhurst serving as chief field assistant; and Ben Wells, a graduate student at the University of West Florida, assisting as well, along with several other Mercyhurst archaeology students.  The Old Vero Man site has been on archaeologists’ radar for more than a century, when the site was discovered as a result of workers who uncovered it while digging the main drainage canal in Vero Beach. At the time, evidence of extinct animals such as mastodons, saber tooth cats, ground sloths, mammoths and other fossils were discovered, along with the now-famous human remains of Old Vero Man, which included skull fragments and 44 bones of a human skeleton.  Of course, Old Vero Man and the archaeological site associated with his discovery have not been without controversy. The discovery itself has long been regarded as controversial and inconclusive, since the age of the human remains were found to be newer than  the extinct animal bones, likely the product of shifting geological layers. Because of this, while the Vero site is still regarded as one of the most significant archeological finds in North America concerning early American inhabitants, questions about the site still remain largely unanswered.  Dr. Adovasio explained in a recent press release that, ”From the beginning, Vero was one of the more infamous archaeological sites in North America because it was seen as such a threat to the then perceived wisdom that no humans had lived here during the last Ice Age,” adding that, “Like Meadowcroft and Monte Verde, it was the subject of vitriolic abuse by the alleged experts at the time. Largely because of that abuse and the less than rigorous field methods, Vero went off the radar. But, because of the phenomenal preservation of Ice Age plant and animal materials at that site, this new excavation will serve to illuminate a time frame in the American Southeast that no other site can, with or without human associations. Whatever information is in there, we are going to get it.”  Adovasio and Hemmings mission in the new dig is to finally bring about a conclusion to the authenticity of the site, and seek to piece it into other insights into early humans on the North American continent. For his part, Adovasio has been at the center of other significant fact-finding archaeological digs such as this one. He was instrumental in managing the meticulous excavation of the Meadowcroft Rockshelter, which is now “widely recognized as the earliest well-dated archaeological site in North America, with evidence of human habitation dating to ca. 16,000 years ago.”  Dr. Hemmings, who an expert on the oldest Paleoindian sites in the U.S., received his master’s and doctoral degrees from the University of Florida, and has extensive field experience in successfully working on ancient and submerged sites throughout Florida. In addition to their proven expertise, both researchers will also bring to bear the latest methods used in modern scientific excavations.  Once the analysis at Mercyhurst of newly discovered artifacts is complete, the plan is for the artifacts to return to Vero Beach for display, according to OVIASC’s Randy Old. OVIASC hopes to create a State of Florida-approved repository in Indian River County for that purpose.  “The new excavation in Vero brings current analytical techniques to the soil layers, bone fragments, seeds, pollen and other materials discovered, and more complete and perhaps new answers to the questions of who were the people found there and how they lived and died,” Old said.

Mike Nace
Texas Biomedical Research Institute
http://bionews-tx.com/news/2014/02/27/new-dig-seeks-solve-mysteries-old-vero-man-site/


Cast from original human skull fragments found in place with mega-fauna fossils at the "Vero Man Site".

Source: Photo taken by Vera Zimmerman (1996) at the Smithsonian Institution Paleontology Archives in Washington D.C.



The bone with the engraving is a long bone, possibly from a mastodon or mammoth.

Photo: Chip Clark / Smithsonian


Researchers from the Smithsonian Institution and the University of Florida have announced the discovery of a bone fragment, approximately 13 000 years old, in Florida with an incised image of a mammoth or mastodon. This engraving is the oldest known example of Ice Age art to depict a proboscidean (the order of animals with trunks) in the Americas. The team's research is published online in the Journal of Archaeological Science.

Photo: Chip Clark / Smithsonian


 Two different views of one tusk (1-2) and bird bone (3) with man made engravings

Uncovered near the Old Vero Man Site by Dr Sellards.

Source: Florida Geological Survey 1916, Eighth Annual Report by Dr Sellards - Plate 22

Human ulna from Vero, found in stratum 3.

Photographed in February of 1916.

Source: Florida Memory - State Library and Archives of Florida


Human radius in position in the canal bank, Vero, Florida

Source: Florida Memory - State Library and Archives of Florida


Close-up of stratum no. 2 at Vero where human remains were found in the canal bank, Vero, Florida

Photographer Sellards, Elias Howard

Source: Florida Memory - State Library and Archives of Florida


Vero human remains

Source: Florida Memory - State Library and Archives of Florida


 Vero human remains

Source: Florida Memory - State Library and Archives of Florida


Photograph showing the ulna, femur and radius in place in the bank.

Photo: Sellards (1917)

http://donsmaps.com/vero.html

 

Charlie Hatchett

www.pre-clovis.com

www.forum.pre-clovis.com

www.blog.pre-clovis.com